Sunday, April 05, 2009

To vote or not to vote - The big Question!!!

With the country heading towards the largest electoral exercise in the world, more than 75 crore Indians will decide the fate of who will govern the country over the next 5 years. And with every passing day, the campaigns are reaching newer levels.


I was in CCD yesterday, when I overheard a conversation from the next table. They were discussing on whether to vote or not to vote. With the type of the public that generally frequents these types of outlets in the country, the discussion was not surprising. Having overheard a few of their thoughts, I just couldn’t smile. We too picked up the same topic and started discussing among ourselves. And the slow service at CCD, in fact gave us enough time to ponder across lengths and breadths of the topic.


The fundamental question which runs in every teenagers mind is whether we should go out and vote in the elections at all. And most of the people who have just acquired their voting rights, unlike me (I was very excited about my first vote in any general election), seem to be over pessimistic about voting. The common reasons given are, the candidates who stand for the elections are not capable enough, there is so much of corruption around, one vote is not going to make any difference to the crores of votes, what’s the point in going and voting when the accessibility to the leaders (or rather representatives) of the people is literally not there and so on and so forth.


The point is not that. I consider voting as a duty rather than a right. More than anything, as responsible citizens of a country, we all should vote. According to me, it’s totally wrong to talk in the air, without being able to justify things. During our debate, one of us told that most of the people who contest elections are all school drop outs and illiterate. But that was a gross understatement. We have ample number of qualified people and by qualified I mean people with real good educational background. We have people with basic graduation degrees to MBA’s from Wharton and Yale and PhD’s from Stanford and Harvard. Of course I do agree that there are people who are illiterate who contest for the elections, but then I am pretty sure that their number can be counted with the fingers.


Coming to the point of educated people being in politics, as long as the people are able to conduct themselves well, as long as they are able to understand life better, and as long as they are able to administrate decently, there is no real need for these big degrees. After all education is supposed to do only this!!


Often candidates standing for the elections are termed as incapable of the job and so on. But majorities of the people, who make these statements, are actually not even aware who is contesting the elections from their area. So how can anyone generalize the statement of candidates being incapable? Of course there will be a fair share of people belonging to that category also. But the best thing to do is find out a bit about the candidates and vote for the most capable person.


Now there is every chance that all are incapable. It does happen. And this is where our system fails. At least earlier, with manual ballots, one had the option of registering an invalid vote, thereby not electing anyone. But with the advent of EVM’s that option is ruled out now. I have read a couple of forwards about provisions being in the constitution for not voting for any candidate, but still registering a vote. I don’t know how far this is actually true. Maybe some research in this area would do some good.


I often come across people who crib about lack of amenities, poor infrastructure in terms of roads, water etc, and corruption in the system etc. What we all fail to understand is that we are a part of the system too. And if the system has a problem, we are a part of the problem. And when we are the part of the problem, part of the solution also lies with us. I always advise people who always complain, to try the system first, and then comment on it. I had this boss of mine, who always used to say, “Unless you have tried something, don’t even say that things are not possible”. I completely agree with him. If you have tried and failed, then you have every right to talk. But without any efforts, talking in the air is actually ridiculous.


Who says there is no system in the country? The system may be delayed, but it still is there. It may be painfully slow, but its there. Or else how would you even explain the powers that the Election Commission is able to execute in enforcing the Model Code of Conduct during the election time. 15 years ago, this was unthinkable. Now, anyone who violates the code stands the sure chance of getting booked under law. What happens next is a different question. But the point I am trying to make, is that things are changing in India, and they are definitely changing for the good.


Many more examples like these can be given, but the essence of these is very simple. India today, is definitely far better than what it was during our parents’ days. And as people of a society, it’s our bounden duty to make it even better for the next generation to live. And believe me it’s not difficult. One classic example I can quote here is that of the massive campaign launched by “Jaagore” in enrolling eligible people in the voters list. Something which has been conceptualized and implemented by some common man like us? If someone can do it, why not us? We only have to introspect, and as ourselves the question. We need to understand that, unless we change, we cannot expect the world to change. I too used to voice the same pessimistic opinions till a few years back. Then I realized that this is simply not the way.


On a concluding note, I would like to emphasize on the fact that, just as in other cases, if you don’t perform your duties, you won’t be eligible for your rights; if you do not vote, you have no right complaining whatever happens in your society. Be it as small an issue as frequent power cuts or as big an issue as a terror attack on your city.

9 comments:

Unknown said...

you have hit the mark. I say voting is our duty as well as a right... if u see it as a right, then by choosing not to vote wud be abusing our own rights with our own hands. ...and as a duty if we don't vote, we fail our first step then n there...then why say politicians don't do their work? aren't we as guilty as they are? its all "chalta hai" attitude that's so present in india that no one wants to go beyond "chalta hai"... " mere ek vote se kya hoga" and "i don';t want to vote and add to the miseries" is sucha wrong thinking.

Prashanth Nayak said...

hey buddy..i agree with most of the thoughts voiced by you..voting is a duty and one must carry it out rightly...but i have something to say on your concluding comment....about cribbing on power cuts or terror attacks, does it mean that you have to crib only if you vote?? power cuts will still continue irrespective of me or you voting or not.. power cuts will be carried out in residential areas with middle class people and BPL people...and you wont see any power cuts in pubs,bars,political parties in hotels etc....only because its about POWER and nothing else....our votes give these people the POWER...which is misused....!!!!! Things are changing in India...definitely...but there are lot of rotten mangoes still left in the bag....!!!

abhishek said...

Hi.. Nitin!! You have brought up a very important topic and made some bold statements. I completely agree that voting is our duty and we must vote. It is the beauty of the democracy that allows every individual irrespective of cast, sex or economic background to voice their opinion. Todays young india is much more mature than what it used to be around 20 years back. However long the journey it should start with the first step..Likewise casting our vote is the first step in taking initiative. If we are complaining about incapable, uneducated people standing in for election and making vows of leading the country to prosperity..What are the so called educated people doing? I tell u what , they are either supporting them or complaining!! We have to express our dissent collectively to bring about or see the change. This can only be expressed by all the people casting their vote. They should understand the value of their single vote. There are a lot of things that need to change and it might take some time but we should also believe we can be responsible for bring the change that we want to see..

Nitin "Engineer" Prabhu said...

@ Purnima and Abhishek,
Thanks for adding voice to the thoughts

@ Prashanth
Thanks for making the discussion interesting

The point here is not whether to crib or not to crib. I know that even after you and me vote, things are not going to change drastically. But without me and you voting, things are not going to improve. Its as simple as it.

We definitely deserve security in the country, there is no way I am challenging that fact. But tomorrow, should something wrong happen, how can someone even think of pointing fingers at others??

Things cannot change overnight. Please recall those days, when in your and my school days, the frequency of power cuts and also the duration of the cuts. And compare them with what it is today, at the same place. Hasnt it changed? and changed for the better? It definitely has. Its only that change cant happen overnight. It has to happen gradually.

Believe me,things today are definitely better than what it was a decade ago. You could never have imagined the powers which the Election Comission is exercising today, say 20 years ago. Justice is definitely being delivered faster; it may still be slow, but its definitely better than the past.

And change cannot happen by sitting and cribbing. It requires involvement of the people. And for a system to function, the people in the system to function. Nothing can sustain on itself.

And finally, as I have already said, just drawing analogy to what Bill Gates once said - "If you are born poor, its not your mistake; but if you die poor, its your mistake!!!". We can say, "Its not our mistake that the society and system was thus, when we came into existence. But ensuring that its better when we leave, is definitely our responsibility"

SWATZ said...

This was such an enlightening and strking posts of your entire lot that I have read till now.I totally agree with you that by simply cribbing about the existing system we are doing no good to anybody. Unless and until we take the bull by its horns, actually go and cast our vote their, we cannot expect the system to function as per our desires. We really have to realize our responsibility that by submitting a simple push of the button we bring some difference in the world, if not all. in addition to this, we have to make sure that we vote for the right candidate who deserves out vote. Randomly voting for anybody is as good as not voting.

But Today's generation is not at all pessimistic. we are young, vibrant and reday to take on the world. We are aware out responsibility towards the society and are ever-ready to do whatever it takes to change the system. And nobosy dare underestimate our power. =))

I loved the concluding paragraph...Frequent powere cuts are part and parcel of common man's life in India. But simply complainign and blaming the Government is useless because We are the ones who only elected them in power 5 yrs back.

So this time make sure that we vote for the RIGHT person who can at least ensure 24 hours of uninterrupted power supplies to our den.

Thanks bro for posting this Vote write-up. Now I am all charged up to go and cast my vote on May 7th...Really looking forward to Voting for the first time.. =)))

Keep Posting and Rocking the world.... Love ya!!!

Prashanth Nayak said...

@ Nitin

You can say that things have improved drastically for past 20 years. But if you see the bigger picture, lot of other countries have improved leaps and bounds in the same 20 years.Australia,Japan,Korea to name a few...And a major part of this is mainly due to the political system that prevails in these countries and hence the governance. People can vote the right candidates, but it so happens that once they have the power, they do not focus on doing what they have been voted for!!! And can this mindset improve easily?? Also a national party (so called) has brought out its manifesto saying it would focus on non-computerisation and non-english based education. Are we to vote for such people??? Even if we don't vote for them, it so happens that , to form a govt, these people act king makers and the situation is back to square one!!!

Nitin "Engineer" Prabhu said...

@ Prashanth

I agree with you completely. Our system is bad, no doubt about it. We are governed by corrupt people, no second thought about it. Our development is definitely not on par with other countries that you have mentioned. Take the case of America, all the people in the cabinet have the right qualifications to do the job they are handling. And once their terms are over, they get back to what they were doing earlier.

But the point I am trying to make is simply this. Please try to get my point. If we dont want to elect corrupt people, we have to ensure that we have a better alternative. Once again, it starts from us. One among us has to stand and offer to represent the people. What stops good, clean, non corrupt people to stand up and say "Yes, Please elect me, I ll take care of you!!" I can give you one classic example. I am sure you remember there was an attempt made during the last general elections, where graduates from IIT's and IIMs had floated a party called Lok Paritan. And they had made an impact. But today, nobody knows where they are!! Another example is one IAS officer, has quit from his job and is contesting for Lok Sabha from a constituency in Hyderabad. He has floated a party called Loksatta. And the type of wave he has been able to create is simply tremendous. I am sure that he is going to win by a comfortable majority. Only thing to be ensured, is that maintain the consistency. Sustain the wave. There is no need to make hi fi promises. But stick to the promises that are made. A single candle can light a million lamps. A journey of a thousand miles, has to begin with the first step. So the essence is to make a beginning.

S 4 Sandeep said...

Maamu Nice Blog indeed .. Hype inspires people to talk so much .. and because it is Hype, its not real .. and so they miss out on action .. Voting indeed is action which needs much to think about than to talk ..

Dr Roshan Radhakrishnan said...

I don't know, Nithin. I've read all that you have to say and even seen the enthusiasm of those who've commented.. I feel bad injecting my pessimism into this midst. The fact is as I explained in my post, if you really do believe thre is a worthy candidate in your constituency , definitely vote for him...
The reason for my pessimism is that I've been through this.. through two changes of government - the major two. Both the times we waited for change... and nothing did. India moved forward inspite of the elected politicos, not because of them..
I mean, c'mon yaar. Can anyone tell me what is the fixed agenda for anti-terrorism by any of these parties ? How they plan to resolve the Kashmir issue or Babri ?
The fact is they all say they'll do it, just give them the chair.. but noone knows how.
And the saddest part is - you have no guarentees which parties are gonna side together !! People with totally different ideologies are ready to get togethr as long as they get their seat... then what exactly are we voting for when the parties themselves cant promise us what their stand on various issues are ?
Case in point : Jayalalitha taking a U-turn and sympathising with the LTTE seeing Karunanidhi scoring brownie points with the Tamil public. Or Mulayalam's cases vanishing after he supported the PM during the nuclear deal no trust vote last year..

Trust me, dont let my grouchiness spoil your enthusiasm.. like you, i and my batchmates too were really enthu abt it years back.. hopefully, unlike us back then, your vote may actually lead to a better India